Judge or Jury? How Judge-Alone Trials Work in Queensland
CRIMINAL LAW · TRIALS
Judge or jury? How judge-alone trials work in Queensland
If you have pleaded not guilty to an indictable offence in Queensland, your matter will proceed to trial, where the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. In Queensland, the default position is trial by jury. But in some circumstances a trial can be heard by a judge sitting alone - and whether to seek one is a strategic decision.
A common misconception is that an accused person can simply choose between a judge and a jury. In Queensland, that is not the law. A judge-alone trial requires a no jury order under sections 614 and 615 of the Criminal Code (Qld). Either the defence or the prosecution may apply, but the court will only make the order if satisfied it is in the interests of justice to do so - and where the prosecution applies, the accused must consent. The application must also be made before the trial begins (when the jury panel attends), and if the identity of the trial judge is already known, the court also needs special reasons to make the order. So this is a decision to confront early, with advice, not at the courtroom door.
01 / WHEN MIGHT A JUDGE-ALONE
When might a judge-alone trial be sought?
Section 615(4) of the Criminal Code lists circumstances that may support a no jury order - a trial so complex or long it would be unreasonably burdensome to a jury, a real possibility of juror intimidation, and significant pre-trial publicity - and other considerations can be relevant:
- Complex or technical evidence. Where a trial turns on lengthy financial records, scientific evidence, or intricate legal questions, a judge's legal training can be an advantage in ensuring the issues are decided on the law rather than impression.
- Pre-trial publicity. Where a matter has attracted significant media attention, there is a real risk that potential jurors come to court with views already formed. A judge alone is better placed to quarantine the evidence from the coverage.
- Confronting or emotive evidence. Where the allegations or the evidence are especially distressing, a judge is trained to assess it dispassionately, and gives reasons for the verdict - something a jury never does.
- Practical considerations. Judge-alone trials avoid jury empanelment and can be shorter and less expensive.
02 / WHEN IS A JURY THE BETTER FORUM?
When is a jury the better forum?
A jury remains a powerful protection, and in many trials it is the right choice. Twelve members of the community bring a diversity of perspective, and where a case turns on questions of ordinary human judgment - honesty, reasonableness, how people actually behave - community standards matter. Indeed, under section 615(5) the court may refuse a no jury order where the trial will involve a factual issue requiring the application of objective community standards, such as reasonableness or dangerousness. Where the defence case is that a complainant is mistaken or untruthful, the collective assessment of twelve people can be more favourable terrain than the analysis of one.
03 / THE DECISION IS CASE-SPECIFIC
The decision is case-specific
There is no universally safer forum. The right answer depends on the charge, the evidence, the issues in dispute, and the risks particular to your matter - which is why it is a decision to make with advice, early, and on the specific facts of your case.
Source: Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) (current as at 29 October 2026), ss 614 and 615. The law and penalties change from time to time, so please get advice about your own matter before relying on this general information.
05 / SPEAK WITH US
Speak with Aegis Law Group
Facing trial in Queensland? Call Aegis Law Group on (07) 3709 7610 or request a call below for a confidential discussion.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Get advice on your specific situation.
(07) 3709 7610 BRISBANE OFFICE33 Queen Street, Brisbane


